Cleisthenes and Democracy

The Reforms of Cleisthenes - 508 BCE

Isagoras backed by Cleomenes against Cleisthenes the Alcmaionid

Cleisthenes 'takes the people into his party'

Cleomenes intervenes and is expelled from Acropolis

Cleisthenes reforms the political organization of Athens

deme affiliation replaces aristocratic clan allegiance

oikos - household	deme – township
genos – family, clan	trittys – "third", county
phratry – "brotherhood", family	phyle - tribe

ten tribes replace the traditional four

- composed of demes from different areas of Attica

- trittyes of coast, plains, and city

Boule (Council) of 500 - prytanies of 50 from each tribe

Ecclesia of all the citizens

Heliaia – the peopleπs courts

Graphe Paranomon and Eisangelia

Sparta and Athenian politics

Ostracism in Athens

Athens and Persia

King Cleomenes in Conflict with King Demaratus

∑ Athens and Isagoras – Boeotia, Euboea, and Eleusis

∑ Aegina Crisis – 491

∑ Cleomenes at Argos – Battle of Sepeia

∑ Tales about Demaratus

The Expulsion of Demaratus and Rise of King Leotychides

The Fall of Leotychides and Cleomenes

Readings:

Buckley ch. 9

Herodotus Books VI-IX

Fornara 55

Plutarch – Themistocles and Aristides

Review Herodotus' account of the rulers of the Persian empire - Cyrus, Cambyses, and Darius. How does he shape the story of each ruler's career?

What are the causes of the Ionian revolt in Herodotus' account? What are his sources and how may we assess their value?

In Herodotus' account of Marathon, the details included provide insight into Greek culture and values. What do the facts that Herodotus chose to relate about Miltiades reveal about the importance of participation in the Olympian and other Panhellenic games as a factor in Greek politics? What role did visions and dreams play in Herodotus' account? What cracks in Athenian unity intruded almost immmediately into the picture of heroic action?

How does Herodotus' account of Xerxes decision to invade compare with his earlier account of Dariusπs decision to send out the first expeditions against Greece? Note especially the role of Artabanos, who plays the part of a type-character frequently found in Herodotus, the Tragic Warner. How might recognition of such type-characters be used in the assessment of the historicity of Herodotus' account?

Compare the accounts in Herodotus and Fornara 55 of the evacuation of Athens and the role of Themistokles. Who is left behind on the Acropolis? When do the Athenians abandon the city?

Compare the accounts of the battle of Salamis by Aeschylus and Herodotus. What has Aeschylus omitted, and how trustworthy is a drama as a source? The passage about Artemisia provides evidence about the historianπs treatment of women; what may have been his motivation in focusing on her actions?

New Organization after the Reforms of Cleisthenes

TRIBE	City Trittyes	Plains Trittyes	Coast Trittyes
Erectheis	Euonymon	Kephisia	Lamptrai
Aigeis	Kollytos	Epaktria	Halai Araphenides
Pandionis	Kydathenaion	Paiania	Myrrhinous
Leontis	Skambonidai	Eupyridai	Phrearrhioi
Akamantis	Kerameikos	Sphettos	Thorikos
Oineis	Lakiadai	Pedieis	Thriasioi
Kekropis	Melite	Phyla	Aixone
Hippothontis	Piraeus	Dekeleia	Eleusis
Aiantis	Phaleron	Aphidna	Tetrapoleis
Antiochis	Alopeke	Pallene	Anaphlystos

Four Former Tribes in Attica: Geleontes, Hopletes Argadeis, Aigikoreis

from Aeschylus, Persians (330-470) – contrast Herodotus VIII. 56-103

Atossa: Alas! The words I hear put the very crown upon our woes; a disgrace to the Persians and cause for shrill lament. But retrace your tale and tell me this clearly: [335] how great was the number of the Greek ships which gave them confidence enough to go into battle with their armed prows against the Persian army?

Messenger: If numbers had been the only factor, be assured that the barbarians would have gained the victory with their fleet. For the whole number of the ships of Hellas amounted to ten times thirty, [340] and, in addition to these, there was a chosen squadron of ten. But Xerxes, this I know, had under his command a thousand, while those excelling in speed were twice a hundred, and seven more. This is the total of their respective numbers. Do you think that we were simply outnumbered in this contest? [345] No, it was some divine power that tipped the scale of fortune with unequal weight and thus destroyed our host. The gods preserve the city of the goddess Pallas.

Atossa: Is then the city of Athens not yet despoiled?

Messenger: No, while her men still live, her ramparts are impregnable. [350]

Atossa: But the beginning of the encounter of the fleets, tell me about it. Who began the onset? Was it the Hellenes? Or my son, exulting in the multitude of his ships?

Messenger: My Queen, some destructive power or evil spirit, appearing from somewhere or other, caused the beginning of our utter rout. [355] A Hellene, from the Athenian host, came to your son Xerxes and told this tale: that, when the gloom of black night should set in, the Hellenes would not remain in place, but, springing upon the rowing benches of their ships, would seek, some here, some there, [360] to preserve their lives by stealthy flight. But Xerxes, when he heard this, comprehending neither the cleverness of the Greek nor that the gods grudged him success, straightway gave all his captains orders to this effect--that, when the sun had ceased to illumine the earth with his beams, [365] and darkness had covered the region of the sky, they should bring up in a tight group the main body of the fleet, disposed in triple line, to bar the exits and the sounding straits, and station other ships in a circle around the island of Ajax. He gave them a warning too that, should the Hellenes escape an evil doom, [370] finding by stealth some means of flight for their fleet, it had been decreed that every captain should lose his head. These commands he made with complete confidence of heart, since he knew not the issue intended by the gods. Our crews then, with no lack of order but with an obedient spirit, [375] prepared their evening meal, while each sailor looped his oar about its thole-pin so that it fitted well. But when the light of the sun had faded and night drew on, each master of an oar and each man versed in arms went on board. [380] The long galleys cheered each other, line by line; and they held their course as each captain had been ordered, and all through the night the commanders of the fleet kept their whole force cruising to and fro across the strait. Night began to wane, [385] yet the fleet of the Hellenes in no way attempted to put forth by stealth. When, however, radiant Day with her white horses shone over all the land, a loud cheer like a song of triumph first rang out from the Hellenes, and, at the same instant, [390] clear from the island crags, an echo returned an answering cry. Terror fell on all the barbarians, balked of their purpose; for then the Hellenes chanted their solemn paean, not as in flight, but as men rushing to the onset with the courage of gallant hearts.

[395] The trumpet with its blast set all their side afire, and instantly, at the word of command, with the even stroke of foaming oars they struck the briny deep. Swiftly they all came clear into view. Their right wing, well marshalled, [400] led on in orderly advance, next their whole army pressed on against us, and at the same time a loud shout met our ears: "On, you men of Hellas! Free your native land. Free your children, your wives, the temples of your fathers' gods, [405] and the tombs of your ancestors. Now you are fighting for all you have." Then from our side arose in response the mingled clamor of Persian speech, and straightaway the ships dashed together their bronze prows. It was a ship of Hellas [410] that began the charge and chopped off in its entirety the curved stern of a Phoenician boat. Each captain drove his ship straight against some other ship. At first the stream of the Persian army held its own. When, however, the mass of our ships had been crowded in the narrows, and none could render another aid, [415] and each crashed its bronze prow against each of its own line, they splintered their whole bank of oars. Then the Hellenic galleys, not heedless of their chance, hemmed them in and battered them on every side. The hulls of our vessels rolled over, and the sea was hidden from our sight, [420] strewn as it was with wrecks and slaughtered men. The shores and reefs were crowded with our dead, and every ship that formed a part of the barbarian fleet plied its oars in disorderly flight. But, as if our men were tuna or some haul of fish, [425] the foe kept striking and hacking them with broken oars and fragments of wrecked ships. Groans and shrieks together filled the open sea until the face of black night hid the scene. But as for the the full extent of our disasters, this, even if I had ten days in succession to do so, I could not describe to you. [430] However, you can be sure that so great a multitude of men never perished in a single day.

Atossa: Alas! In truth a vast sea of troubles has burst upon the Persians and the entire barbarian race. [435]

Messenger: Be assured of this, not even half of the disaster has as yet been told. A calamity so dreadful as to outweigh these ills twice over befell them.

Atossa: But what greater misfortune than this could have befallen them? Speak! What is this other disaster you say [440] came upon our force, sinking the scale to greater weight of ill?

Messenger: Those Persians who were in their life's prime, bravest in spirit, pre-eminent for noble birth, and always among the foremost in loyalty to the King himself-- these have fallen ignobly by a most inglorious doom. [445]

Atossa: Ah, I am truly reduced to misery through this disaster! By what fate was it that you say they met their end?

Messenger: There is an island lying before Salamis, a small one and dangerous anchorage for ships; its sea-washed shore is the haunt of Pan, who loves the dance. [450] There Xerxes dispatched these, his choicest troops, in order that when the Hellenic enemy, wrecked from their ships, should flee in search of safety to the island, they might slaughter their force, an easy prey, and rescue their comrades from the straits of the sea. Grievously did he misjudge the issue. For when some god [455] had given the glory to the Hellenes in the battle on the sea, on that same day, fencing their bodies in armor of bronze, they leapt from their ships and encircled the whole island, so that our men were at a loss which way to turn. Often they were struck by stones slung from their hands, [460] and arrows sped from the bow-string kept falling upon them and doing them harm. At last the Hellenes, charging with one shout, struck them and hacked to pieces the limbs of the poor wretches, until they had utterly quenched the life of all. [465] Xerxes groaned aloud when he beheld the extent of the disaster, for he occupied a seat commanding a clear view of the entire army--a lofty headland by the open sea. Tearing his robes and uttering a loud cry, he straightaway gave orders to his force on land [470] and dismissed them in disorderly flight. This, besides the one already told, is the disaster you must bewail.